With time running out before a decision is made on the fate of the Bengeo Quarry, the work to oppose the proposal is increasing. Stop Bengeo Quarry and the Molewood Residents Association have been distributing leaflets to residents explaining the revised application, why we believe it should be rejected and what you can do to help. The full details can be found at the end of this article.
- The final deadline to object is the 23rd February. If you haven’t done so already, please send your comments to:
HCC Planning Officer Ms Felicity Hart
Spatial Planning & Economy Unit CHN216
County Hall
Pegs Lane
Hertford
SG13 8DN
or email spatialplanning@hertfordshire.gov.uk quoting reference number PL\0776\16 - There is a landscape survey for all who use and view Bengeo Field at http://stopbengeoquarry.org.uk/2017/01/23/landscape-survey/. This will help provide SBQ with details about how you feel about the field and how often it is used. The survey should take no longer than 5 minutes to complete.
- An online petition is available to sign here. A signed petition can’t take the place of a written objection, but by signing the petition in addition, the case of the SBQ position will be strengthened.
- The HCC Development Control Committee hearing will be on Wednesday 22 March at 10am sharp in County Hall, where the proposal will be discussed and the decision will be made. Please note that the date is subject to final confirmation, and if delayed, the next Committee meeting is scheduled for 26 April at 10am. Look out for further updates in local shops and street boards confirming the date. If you can attend please show your opposition to the quarry – it will really help.
If you’d like to find out more about the quarry you can view Stop Bengeo Quarry’s website, or type ‘quarry’ into the search field on this website.
The proposal, objections and ways you can help
The original application to extract gravel from Bengeo Field just outside Hertford was made at the start of the Easter holidays last year. Despite the depth of opposition among local residents, the developers re-submitted a revised application – this time at the start of the Christmas holiday. The Herts County Council (HCC) have opened a new public consultation about this revised proposal – with a tight deadline of 23 February. We hope this leaflet will provide you with the information you need when submitting your response. It is really the last time the residents can ensure the HCC knows what we think and want. Once the decision is made by HCC Development Control Committee we have no option to appeal.
The strength of local opposition to the quarry in response to the original application has had an effect. The period and the volume of gravel extraction have been reduced. However, the area of the quarry is proposed to remain unchanged and the character of the Bengeo Field landscape will be lost permanently.
The threat to the landscape and wildlife remains. The health concerns related to gravel extraction remain. The impact of the quarry on the water supply and highways remains a concern. And the good faith of the developers behind this application must also be a concern; it is an insult to local residents to play politics with the timing of their applications. How can local residents feel confident that the developers will behave any better in the future? And why would anyone wish to see Bengeo Field sacrificed for the sake of private interests?
Frustrating though it is to have to oppose the Bengeo quarry all over again, if we wish to avoid industrial scale gravel extraction on Bengeo Field it is vital that the concerns of local people are voiced. Please send your objections to HCC Case Officer Ms Felicity Hart and copy your local Councillors and MP, quoting ref number PL\0776\16:
Felicity J Hart, Spatial Planning & Economy Unit CHN216, County Hall, Pegs Lane, Hertford, SG13 8DN, or spatialplanning@hertfordshire.gov.uk.
Cllr Dr Andrew Stevenson, andrew.stevenson@hertfordshire.gov.uk
MP Mark Prisk, office@hertford-stortfordconservatives.net
Cllr Peter Ruffles, Peter.Ruffles@eastherts.gov.uk
Cllr Paul Phillips, Paul.Phillips@eastherts.gov.uk
Cllr Patricia Moore, Patricia.Moore@eastherts.gov.uk
John Wood, HCC Chief Executive & Director of Environment, john.wood@hertfordshire.gov.uk
Jim McManus, HCC Director Public Health, jim.mcmanus@hertfordshire.gov.uk
Herts Health and Wellbeing Board, hwb.herts@hertfordshire.gov.uk
Jenny Cole, HCC Director of Children’s Services, jenny.coles@hertfordshire.gov.uk
HCC Development Control Committee – Wednesday 22 March at 10am, County Hall The decision about the Bengeo quarry proposal will be taken by the Committee. We will represent the Stop Bengeo Quarry objections. Please come and show your support. If the hearing is delayed, the next Committee meeting is on 26 April 10 am – please look out for updates in local shops and notice boards.
The developer submitted the following adjustments to the quarry application in response to the objections and concerns raised at the earlier consultation:
- The amount of gravel removed will be reduced by 33% from 2.6 million tonnes to 1.75 million tonnes.
- The period of the gravel excavation will be reduced from 15 to around 10 years.
- The area affected by the quarry remains the same.
- An originally proposed flat base of 12 metres deep and steep banks at the sides will be replaced by an undulating base with a bank of 8 meters to the north of the site. There will be more gradual slopes on restored land leading to higher final levels.
- Bund/bank across the southern end of phase 1 (opposite The Orchard) will be increased in height from 3 to 4 metres.
- Use of the byway will be removed for 5-10 years. Developers don’t show how this walking route will be retained in anything like its current form.
- The Lonely Oak tree and three oaks will be retained. Undisturbed area around three trees will increase from 10 metres to 15 metres.
- “In view of the site being within the groundwater catchment of the public water supply borehole at Wadesmill, the Environmental Agency policy allows mineral extraction (subject to conditions) but does not allow material to be imported to aid restoration. Therefore, to satisfactorily address the landscape concern, the depth of the excavation needs to be restricted.”
- The access road remains separate from the Rickneys access road.
- The developer assumes that there will not be much impact on school/Hertford traffic and estimates traffic impact at only 4%. This includes Rickneys quarry reopening but assumes equal traffic flows per hour.
- The Air Quality Report submitted by the developer concludes that “there will be no unacceptable impacts to the air quality locally. The local concern on health based on the possible deterioration of air quality which the report shows to be misplaced.”
- If the wind is blowing NE (towards the school and allotments) operations in phase 1 will be subject of “sequential mitigation”. First there will be “initial visual inspection by the site manager to determine the intensity of any emissions”, then “soil dampening using a water bowser should be undertaken to reduce dust emissions”. “If this process is not sufficient to reduce potential impacts to an acceptable level, operations within the Restricted Working Zone should cease until suitable meteorological conditions return”.
How you can help to stop the Bengeo Quarry
- Send your comments and objections by 23 February to HCC Planning Officer and Councillors. This current consultation is separate and on the new revised proposal. Non-residents of Hertford can also comment. If you miss the deadline, it is still worth sending your letter while the HCC report is being prepared (approx. 3 March).
- Join us at the HCC Development Control Committee on 22 March at 10am in County Hall.
- Show your support and spread the word – display a STOP BENGEO QUARRY poster, follow us for the updates on www.stopbengeoquarry.org.uk/news/ and Facebook group “Stop Bengeo Quarry”, email us on info@stopbengeoquarry.org.uk.
- Sign our on-line petition (but please not instead of your letter to HCC)
- Donate to support the Stop Bengeo Quarry campaign – we agreed to pay for professional advice on the campaign’s response to the consultation. If you wish to donate please pay into our NatWest bank account. Every amount will help. Thank you.
Account Name: Stop Bengeo Quarry Group
Sort Code: 60-10-39
Account Number: 14189135
Our key concerns about the revised Bengeo quarry proposal
Impact on landscape and amenity
- The site is currently an important amenity area for North Hertford and while the quarry is active it will be a largely inaccessible gravel pit.
- The pleasantly rural character of this part of town will be replaced by industrial eyesore and even if restoration proceeds as planned the resulting “hole” will transform a natural landscape – visible from Hertford, the B158 and the surrounding countryside – to a man-made one forever.
- The landscape survey and events organised by Stop Bengeo Quarry provide evidence that many hundreds of local people use the paths on the Bengeo Field for recreation and treasure the landscape and its iconic features, such as the “Lonely Oak”.
- The survival of any trees on or near the site can’t be guaranteed given the significant earthworks and changes in soil level that will be taking place in very close proximity to them.
- The byway across the Bengeo Field will at best be a desolate track through a quarry, transformed from a health walk asset to a health and safety hazard for the large numbers of children, pets and people of all ages who use it every day of the week.
Dust, noise and health issues
- The 2015 consultation document for the new Herts Minerals Local Plan states that “residential properties and other sensitive uses can be affected by dust up to 1km from the source”.
- The UK Health and Safety Executive says breathing crystalline silica particles (a natural substance found in most rocks, sand and clay), can cause lung disease, including silicosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and lung cancer. The existing Minerals Plan does not account for the health risks of silica dust.
- The methods that have been proposed to minimise dust are subjective and will not stop it altogether. The developers state in their proposal that the sand and gravel is damp and will therefore not create dust when dug. However, they are planning to stockpile supplies before loading lorries, which so it is bound to dry out.
- The National Planning Policy Framework states that planners must “ensure in granting planning permission for mineral development there are no unacceptable adverse impacts on… human health”.
- In its response to the developers’ proposal to build this quarry within a few hundred metres of a primary school, Natural Health England said the developers must show there will be no “additional emissions including dust or particulate matter which could adversely affect the local community”.
- Neither of these conditions are met by the revised proposal and the new air quality assessment submitted. The developers have not submitted health impact and noise assessments.
- The quarry developers have said that the noise levels will be very close to the legal limit. This noise would affect residents from 7am until 6pm from Monday to Friday as well as from 7am to 1pm on Saturday. The developers are proposing to use lorries to move sand and gravel around the site instead of a much quieter conveyor system.
- The air quality assessment concludes the risk to the health of children at the school and local residents is negligible but the report’s conclusions are based on what the report authors claim are “robust assumptions”.
- The air quality assessment submitted is based on guidance issued by the Institute of Air Quality Management (IAQM). This guidance comes with an important caveat: “The IAQM does not expect practitioners to follow the suggested approach in all circumstances. Other approaches may also be valid, provided they are based on sound scientific principles.” The approach relies on estimates of mean annual exposure, and states that the (estimated) process contribution to the (estimated) background particulate matter level is unlikely to push the (estimated) total annual mean exposure over the statutory limit. (Because of this, the air quality assessment makes no attempt to measure or predict or even estimate what the actual dust emissions from the quarry will be). This, as the IAQM makes clear, is one approach.
- Another approach, based on the sound scientific principles the IAQM, is to consider the possible daily exposure to particulate matter for children at Bengeo Primary School. As the IAQM guidance points out, “dust impacts will occur mainly within 400m of the operation”. The school is 350m from the proposed site boundary.
- The developers have not provided a measurement or estimate of dust released from their proposed site. Given the uncertainty and the risk to the health of vulnerable children as well as adults with respiratory issues, the proposal cannot be permitted to proceed without this information.
Negative impact on the ecology and wildlife
- An independent environmental assessment of local wildlife should be conducted to address concerns about the following key species: skylarks, brown hare, badgers. The suggestion that brown hare and skylarks can move to other areas fails to take responsibility for the care of wildlife. The proposed protection of badger population is also inadequate.
- Concerns about the impact on the adjacent precious ecology of St. John’s Wood and the possible impact of groundwater levels have not been addressed. In the new plans an 8 metre bank to the south of St. John’s Wood is retained but there is no assessment of its impact on local hydrology.
Highways and traffic concerns
- Proposal takes no account of peaks in traffic associated with the site nor the operation of the site entrance at those busiest times. The lorry movement will not be spread evenly throughout the day. There is likely to be a big impact of queuing lorries waiting for the entrance to open during the morning rush hour and have a potentially dangerous impact on children arriving at Bengeo Primary School. The presence of additional gravel lorries, made worse if Rickneys were to reopen before its December 2017 deadline, would only compound this problem as well as worsening air quality in the area
- The developer assumes that traffic patterns would be the same all year round. Winter operations would be over a shorter day than in the summer, we would have expected this to be reflected into the trip generation and traffic modelling.
- Although the amended scheme would involve reduced extraction of gravel, it would not impact on traffic congestion or road safety since the rate of extraction would be unchanged.
- HGV traffic generated by the site is described as 100 two-way trips in the TS and ES but the latter definition is qualified with word ‘average’. In our view the B158 is not safe enough to cope with an average of an extra 100 HGV movements a day. No mention is made as to how the applicant would monitor and enforce this vital movement restriction.
- The site would be accessed by vehicle from a new access junction in a dip in the B158 Wadesmill Road opposite the footpath from Watermill Lane. The HCC specification for Preferred Area 2 in its Minerals Local Plan requires that the whole area is accessed via the existing Rickneys pit access road.
- Our concern is that drivers keen to win loads for their clients/ employers would arrive at or before the opening time and have nowhere safe to wait. The developer does not explain how they would manage the arrival of trucks prior to and immediately after site opening.
- An inevitable feature of all minerals extraction operations is mud on roads leading to/from the site entrance.
Water supply concerns
- Six million litres of water a day come to Hertford from boreholes within the field proposed to quarry at the Wadesmill Road pumping station. Extraction so close to the boreholes within this high protection zone is at a clear risk of pollution to Hertford’s water supply. This risk has been identified by Hafren Water, consultants to the quarry developer. There is potential for pollution from extraction or fuelling.
- By the time any pollution is detected, lasting damage may well have been done to the aquifer. Monitoring is not the main issue, prevention is the key.
- Assessment of the chance of successful prevention of pollution requires a detailed map of the buried chalk surface, and a survey of the size and orientation of fractures within the chalk aquifer. Such information has not been presented by the applicant.
- Avoidance of damaging pollution might in principle be achieved at this site, but only by significant investment in pre-operational surveys, in equipment and in training of staff.
- World-class levels of maintenance and supervision would have to be sustained by an experienced operator throughout the lifetime of the project.
- The sand and gravel it is proposed to quarry are not essential for the local or national community. What is essential is that we have an uncontaminated supply of water to Hertford.
- The Environment Agency advised the HCC that monitoring of the potential pollution will be sufficient.
Proximity to Bengeo Primary School and local residents
- Parents of Bengeo School children and Bengeo residents are concerned that a 10-year daily exposure to quarry dust and noise being produced just 320m from the school and 30m from some houses could represent an unacceptably high risk to our health.
Need for more gravel
- HCC has an obligation to maintain a landbank of permitted reserves to meet demand for at least 7 years. When the Bengeo field application was submitted the landbank stood at 11.3 years (or 9.5 years using a different estimate of demand). Recently approved Hatfield Aerodrome quarry adds 8mt to the 13.22mt permitted reserves so the total is now 21.22mt.
- Hertfordshire’s annual ‘apportionment’ is 1.39mt so the landbank is now 15.27 years (21.22 / 1.39).
- The new Minerals Local Plan deciding on the new preferred areas in Hertfordshire is now expected to be open to public consultation in May-June this year.
